by Barney Wells, DMin
Director, The Fred Craddock Center for Preaching Excellence

Sermon illustrations. You can buy books of them, you can keep files of them, you can find them on internet preaching websites for free or behind a paywall (is that where the “better” ones are?). But what are they, really? In almost any creative context other than a sermon, an illustration is a picture that accompanies text. An “illustrated history of…” will not only include a written account of the subject matter, but will also contain photos, paintings, maps, charts etc. Most instruction manuals include not only step-by-step instructions in words, but also have drawings or photos showing what to do in that step. The illustration helps make clear and visual what the text may leave unclear and fuzzy. In this third and final post in the series, we look at Enriching the Sermon with illustration.

Dr. Craddock, in his book Preaching, claimed that good sermons often don’t need illustrations (p. 204). If the sermon is well-constructed and well-delivered, it can connect the message of the text with the life of the listeners in a way that is clear and interesting. What preachers often call illustrations are, as Craddock says, “do not illustrate a point, they are the point.” Nathan didn’t preach a sermon to David about taking what belongs to someone else, then illustrate with a story about a lamb. The story was the sermon. The same can be said for Jesus’ message about righteousness and forgiveness—He didn’t illustrate the sermon with story of the two sons, it was the sermon.

So, illustrations are not always necessary in a sermon, but sometimes they are very useful. When you have to present a difficult theological or cultural concept in a sermon, the listeners will be helped if, in addition to stating it, you illustrate it. So here are some of Dr. Craddock’s guidelines for illustrations (in some places quoted, in other paraphrased).

  • The best illustrations come not from books or internet collections of “sermon illustrations,” but from the preacher’s shared experiences with the congregation. In other words, find things that both you and the listeners understand from experience, that will help sharpen the understanding of the point to be made. Find (or create) the familiar to illustrate the unfamiliar.
  • Be sure the analogy between the concept or thought you are illustrating and the illustration is clear, lest the listener mentally wander off think about something else your illustration suggested to them.
  • Illustrations should be simple, but not small or silly. While they need to be easy to understand and brief, they should not oversimplify.
  • Illustrations should not be “thundered” as an exhortation. They should help the listener relax and understand, not feel compelled or threatened.
  • Do not illustrate or explain the illustration, and do not apply it. If an illustration needs to be illustrated, or if you need to tell the listeners what it means, don’t use it—it isn’t a good illustration.
  • Present an illustration without apology or rationalization. Don’t announce it as an illustration, or the listeners won’t take it seriously. Don’t say “I see…” or “we find…” You shouldn’t need to tell the listener what to get from the illustration. If you do need to, it’s not a good illustration. Don’t introduce it as an often-told story, or the listeners will feel they are being served leftovers.
  • Illustrations, especially stories, can have a significant emotional impact, both on the listeners and on the preacher. Be sure you can get through the story your voice breaking, and that the effect on the congregation isn’t traumatic (it can be moving, but not traumatizing).
  • Some illustrative material in a sermon needs a sort of verbal “footnote.” Don’t use someone else’s story unless you give them credit.
  • If you use a quotation as an illustration, and the power is in the source, then give a full attribution. If the quotation is used because of its content (what it says rather then who said it), then you could simply attribute it to “the poet” or “Longfellow,” and the curious listener could ask you after the service if more details are wanted.
  • Be very careful using stories from your own pastoral conversations and experiences, even ones at previous churches. Never share anything told to you by a congregant without permission (and that includes your immediate family).
  • If you are creative, you may be able to “create” a story. Preachers in the Bible, including Jesus, did that. Just be sure you don’t give the impression it is other than fiction. We all know when a story starts with “once upon a time,” we are meant to understand it as fiction.
  • As we have mentioned in other posts in the Sermon Crafting Blog, be careful about self-disclosure in stories. Be wary of casting yourself as the hero, or of confessing your deepest sins in a sermon. Dr. Craddock suggests thinking of yourself as the cameraman, showing the audience an interesting story, but keeping yourself on the edge of it. You may introduce it as your experience, but quickly move the focus to a different central character.

So, try to work with language and description and illustration to enrich the form of your sermons. Not everything you try may be a smashing success, but with practice you will find your sermons richer, and your listeners more attentive and responsive, and so you are all blessed.